Who produced the most improved mind mapping software of 2009? Share your opinion!
Dec 17th, 2009 | By Chuck Frey | Category: Discussion
I’m really excited by the continued growth of mind mapping technology, and its growing acceptance by businesses worldwide.
During 2009, a number of developers of mind mapping software have made major commitments to improving their products to meet the needs of today’s executives and knowledge workers. I’d like to recognize their investment in these productivity tools, which are the right solutions for many of today’s business needs.
Therefore, I have decided to launch a contest, in which you – the readers of this blog – will help me to identify the most improved mind mapping software of 2009.
As part of this contest, I first need to summarize what each developer has accomplished in 2009 to improve its product. After you’ve read that, you can then proceed to a very brief online survey to tell me which program should be the winner of this new award.
Here’s a brief synopsis of how each of the major mind mapping programs has been improved during 2009, in alphabetical order:
ConceptDraw MINDMAP
During 2009, developer CS Odessa launched a new version of their flagship mind mapping program called ConceptDraw MINDMAP for Projects. ConceptDraw MINDMAP 6 offers an impressive set of expanded tools for exporting your maps to PowerPoint, including a choice of numerous PowerPoint templates and several options for parsing the contents of your mind map into slides, how to handle floating topics, notes and slide numbering. Click here for my review of ConceptDraw MINDMAP 6.
DropMind Desktop
Seavus, an enterprise software developer based in Sweden, simultaneously launched a new mind mapping program that is available in desktop and web-based versions in April, 2009. Called DropMind, these programs are well-designed and easy to use. Significant features include the ability to conduct Google and Delicious searches from within DropMind; you can also search Flickr and Live to locate images to add to your mind maps. In addition, DropMind offers seamless integration between the desktop and web-based versions of its application; all that’s required is a single click on a “synchronize” button and the program does the rest. In early December, Seavus launched version 1.1 of DropMind, with additional business features, including support for task information, map parts and an Application Programming Interface (API), which will make it possible for other developers to add functionality to DropMind. Click here to read my review of DropMind.
iMindMap
In May, Buzan Online launched version 4.0 of iMindMap, which featured a powerful new presentation mode, which incorporates a two-screen setup (as presenter, you see the slide and your notes; your audience sees only the current slide), audio notes, floating topics, enhanced support for importing Word documents into mind maps, and printing improvements for large maps. In October, the developer released iMindMap version 4.1, with 21 new map templates, and support for importing and exporting OPML files (a form of XML used for outlining documents that contain hierarchical data, such as web feeds and text outlines). In general, iMindMap became more business focused in its features and functionality during 2009. Click here for my review of iMindMap version 4.
MindGenius
MindGenius version 3.0 debuted in October, and features a new ribbon-style toolbar (a la Microsoft Office 2007 applications), advanced map filtering, improved task handling, categories for “tagging” content within your maps, sophisticated options for exporting map data to Excel (including support for expandable/contractible “groups” and the ability to selectively decide which elements of your maps to export). In addition, MindGenius now offers “question sets,” which are included with each template to prompt you with questions that need to be answered in order to create a complete map of that type. Best of all, you can create your own templates and question sets, which make it much easier to roll out MindGenius to a department or team of “newbies” who have had little or no exposure to mind mapping. Click here for my blog post about MindGenius 3.
MindManager
Several years ago, MindManager developer Mindjet introduced its first attempt at creating a collaborative workspace for visual mappers. Called Mindjet Connect, it wasn’t very well integrated into the MindManager program, and as a result only enjoyed limited use by the MindManager user community. In early October, Mindjet released Catalyst, a completely new collaboration tool that integrates an all-new set of secure online workspaces with web conferencing, real-time co-editing of maps in Mindjet’s web-based mind mapping application, and a set of highly flexible map sharing tools to take small-team collaboration and map sharing to a whole new level. You can now easily use Catalyst to share your maps via e-mail, Twitter, Linkedin, Blogger, Typepad, Facebook, WordPress, Y! Bookmarks and over 150 other web-based tools and services. Click here to read my review of Catalyst.
MindMapper
In Febraury, SimTech launched MindMapper 2009, which now incorporates a ribbon toolbar for faster access to common tasks. MindMapper 2009 also includes new ideation meeting templates to support help support the generation of ideas by small teams. These new templates include radiant association, brainstorming, attribute listing, process planning, cause and effect (fishbone) diagrams, backward thinking (start with a goal and work backward toward the present) and SWOT (strengths/weaknesses/opportunities/threats) analysis. What’s nice about these templates is that they include empty topics to prime your brain to fill them – a solid way to leverage the power of your subconscious mind. MindMapper 2009 also includes Post-It style notes that you can use to add visual emphasis to your maps, improved task handling with dependency scheduling and color theme palettes. For more information about what’s new in MindMapper 2009, please visit the application’s what’s new web page.
NovaMind
In October, NovaMind announced that it is developing a version 5 of its innovative NovaMind mind mapping program, which it hopes to release in early 2010. A technology preview was launched in early November, with a beta test program to follow early next year. Based upon a “sneak peek” that I received from NovaMind founder Gideon King, plus what the developer has announced in its blog, NovaMind 5 will feature a new layout engine that will make very efficient use of screen real estate, sophisticated controls for customizing topic images, a new type of map objects called “shapes” that can be used as design embellishments, floating or conventional topics and a new plug-in architecture, which will enable other developers to write plug-in applications to work with NovaMind 5. Click here to read more details about this forthcoming version of NovaMind.
MindView (formerly Open Mind)
In the first quarter of 2009, MatchWare launched version 3 of its MindView mind mapping software (formerly known as Open Mind). This new version includes numerous enhancements and new features that are designed to increase your productivity, while preserving excellent ease of use. In the process, MatchWare pioneers some neat new features that haven’t been seen before in desktop mind mapping software. Version 3 adds a ribbon toolbar, “live preview” of map style changes, a new Work Breakdown Structure format this is highly useful for project management, focus in/out capabilities and some very sophisticated branch calculation tools. Advanced Word and Excel export tools give you an unprecedented level of control over what you want to export and how you want it to appear when you open it in Microsoft’s Office productivity programs. Click here to read my review of MindView 3 Business Edition.
PersonalBrain
This unique visual mapping and knowledge management tool from TheBrain Technologies received a major upgrade in the third quarter of 2009. PersonalBrain 5.5 enables you to generate report from your map data faster and easier. Map display has been enhanced to improve usability in several areas. Also, PersonalBrain’s integrated calendar now supports recurring appointments and enables users to capture more meta data about events and appointments. You can now easily add content from other documents or web pages to your PersonalBrain maps using an integrated screen capture utility. Simply use the tool to select what you want to capture, and PersonalBrain attaches it to the currently-selected map topic. Finally, PersonalBrain 5.5 now includes a spell checker. For more details on this upgrade, please read my blog post here.
Visual Mind
Mind Technologies launched version 11 of Visual Mind in February, 2009. In this version, the developer has streamlined the process for adding new topics to maps, and the program incorporates a floating toolbar that enables you to format topics in place – at the location of the topic, rather than mousing over to the program’s toolbar. Visual Mind 11 now supports floating topics, images, relationship lines, topic borders and callouts, which give you more options for enhancing your mind maps. For more details about Visual Mind 11, please read my review here.
XMind
In 2008, XMind stunned the world by offering a free, open-source version of its mind mapping software program. Since then, this program has enjoyed surprising popularity as an alternative to the moribund FreeMind, which is only developing very slowly these days. In addition, an XMind Pro version offers a fuller feature set for those people who need it. In March of 2009, XMind introduced version 3.0.3, which includes a number of enhancements, including crash recovery (an auto-save feature that helps to prevent data loss if the program should crash), export to the FreeMind map format, enhanced map zooming, a sophisticated find-and-replace tool and an enhanced spell checker, which now checks topic notes, in addition to the topics themselves. Click here to read my analysis of XMind version 3.0.3.
And finally, the link to the survey…
Click here to access the Most Improved Mind Mapping Software survey.
All you evangelists out there, now is the time to get out the vote for your favorite program. Please spread the word wherever possible, including online support forums, Twitter, your blog or e-newsletter (if you publish one) and your colleagues who utilize mind mapping software to improve their efficiency, productivity and creativity. During the next few days, I will be contacting the software vendors highlighted above to ask them to spread the word about this contest, too!
Thanks in advance for your participation in this contest, which I hope will help to highlight the impressive growth of this unique category of productivity software.
Popularity: 8% [?]













iMindMap is simply the best true Mind Mapping software. I love it and thats why I train in and with it. What I question is why is there such an uninteresting example used to promote this software in the review Chuck? Surely there are better examples to use?
But imindmap is not as good as MindGenius 3 which is about as intuitive as one can imagine and as flexible and adaptable in output as anything else available. The people at MindGenius have obviously listened to people who work in the real world and listened to what they need to intuitively, quickly and effectively do everything they need to run a successful business or teach a brilliant class, from brainstorming to project planning, to designing a presentation, all at the click of a button.
2009 has been a year of peculiarities regarding Mind mapping apps. Peculiar because of the fact that Mind mapping is still attempting to be perceived as a mainstream productivity tool 40 years after its formalization by Mr Buzan.
The listed apps are all very well done, and if I were to force myself to think as a traditional Mind mapper; I would say Imindmap has been the most improved Mind mapping app of all listed.
On the other hand, IMO, the most impressive adaptation of multiple tool expressiveness within the list of apps would be MindView. The timeline is just a killer view.
The most functional Mind mapping app in the list would be Mindjet MindManager, as viewed for business usage. A monster of a product, and we need longer lives to discover all the functions.
The most impressive personal productivity tool, IMO, would be Xmind, due to the open source approach. Free is the new model, and Xmind have captured this industry, and scared every developer sh****ss.
BUT; there has been IMO, only one Mind mapping app that has shone more brightly than all of the others during 2009, and that’s Mind mapper developed by Simtech. This product has to be used to be believed, it takes on Mindjet function for function outwith the constraints of the cloud (Catalyst).
Just my opinion based on functionality and results obtained within the business user arena.
Thanks for mentioning XMind.
This lets us believe open source is a right decision.
Thank you, Chuck Frey, you must be best one of the best guru in mind mapping software field!
@Wallace thank you too, for your objective conclusion.
I am one of XMind Team. I must say that, 2009 is a amazing year to XMind. There are more than 240,000 registered users now. We believe there are more users.
Last November, while we did this, we were not sure. We just found many users are using FreeMind, a great open source mind mapping software. Since that, why not let XMind basic version open source, which has similar and even more features than FreeMind. Then users can have more choice. Competition brings improvement.
No matter XMind, or XMind Pro (v3.1.1 now), they are both kept in improvement.
Hope all developers and users better in 2010!
I’ve been using the tech preview of NovaMind 5, and although it’s quite a way from a finished product, what is already there is far better than any other application.
As pointed out, the layout engine is far better than anything else, and keeps your map compact, while allowing you the ultimate flexibility of layout. But they also have some really good ideas for themes, and I like the automatic text color selection to contrast with the background color, and the themed color sets so that your mind map looks great. Also multiple images on topics can be handy, and the newly introduced hyperlinking and embedding that allows for multiple hyperlinks/embedded files per topic is just the way it should be.
All these things are things that nobody else is addressing. It seems to me that they really are thinking through every feature they implement, and although the rollout is taking some time, I think it’s going to be well worth the wait, and in the meantime, the technology preview is great to use.
I think that NovaMind is going to absolutely be the one to watch for next year.
Excuse me Chuck , you have forgotten FreeMind (only 8 600 000 downloads !and more as 1 million in 2009 http://sourceforge.net/search/?type_of_search=soft&words=freemind) and his new fork FreePlane( automatic download on http://sourceforge.net/projects/freeplane/ . It gives many improvments as management of images, color as background and 16 formats of export . The possibilities as filters are also very impressive .
A book about FreeMind in French is available here : you can download free 3 chapters http://www.editions-eyrolles.com/Livre/9782212124484/boostez-votre-efficacite-avec-freemind
Midjet MindManager is the best! no doubts..
[...] To read a brief synopsis of the major mind mapping programs and to cast your vote, click here. [...]
I’m still wondering why I cannot select one of the most popular and innovative online mindmapping platforms, MindMeister (www.mindmeister.com).
In addition to the fact that MindMeister is a true SaaS pure web application (online and offline, platform independent), it has one element that really is worth mentioning: The balance between usability and functionality.
Thanks, everyone, for your thoughtful feedback. Jürgen, this little survey is based on desktop mind mapping software. I will probably follow-up with a separate one on web-based apps, since there’s been so much worthwhile development in that area, too!
@Chuck: Thanks for considering!
Hi Chuck,
.
I read your blog and your regular mails with a lot of interest.
I am Portuguese and in Portugal there is not much information about MindMaps (or MM software), so I am commited in spreading the word, giving workshops and seminars on mindmapping, talking about software solutions, books and other sources of information, and your blog is, of course, frequently mentioned.
I can only applaud this kind of initiative, as for me alone it’s difficult to get to know all the offers in the market, and reading your blog, as well as the results of this survey, will be very useful to recommend to others.
I am addicted to iMindMap – mainly for personal use and to MindManager as a professional tool.
iMindMap (I use v.4.1.2 sind v.beta) is the coolest as it is very simple to use, able to create maps with a really organic look and has a fantastic images’ library to use for free.
MindManager (I use v.8 since v.1? – not sure) is a really professional tool, with fantastic templates from MindJet and from many others and it’s the tool adopted by the company I work for (ORACLE) during business days
Freemind is a tool I also use (used…). It’s free but, anyway, it needs some improvements to be considered as a serious option to the vast commercial offer.
Hope we can keep in touch.
Regards.
Daniel
What about PersonalBrain? The static “zones” for dropping thoughts are conceptually consistent with the cognitive sciences and learning models, and requires no training to instantly become productive. Does it get easier?
Hei John,
The question is; Who produced the most improved mind mapping software of 2009?
While the personal Brain is one of the best Visual mapping/Data base products, it certainly IS NOT a Mind mapping application in the Mind mapping mainstream sense.
While most Mind mapping apps take @ 10 minutes to figure out, the Personal Brain certainly needs considerably more time to master.
It is indeed an excellent product that has probably the widest scope of use of all of the Visual mapping products. I use it regularly . But it’s really is a stretch to say it’s a Mind mapping app.
[...] the holidays, I told you about a new contest that I’m running to identify the commercial mind mapping program that has improved the most in 2009. If you have participated in my brief survey, thank you! I appreciate [...]
As a teacher, I’ve been trying to find a way to use Mindmapping with my students for years. Sure, I’ve had them create them by hand, and I’ve been mapping for over a decade now. But even with all my experience, there was always the “visual” part that some students, especially those with poor fine-motor skills, couldn’t get past.
But this year I received a SmartBoard through a grant I wrote and then, another grant brought me iMindmap 4.1. Combine these two technologies, especially the presentation mode in iMindmap, and it’s simply everything I could have hoped for. I’ve had students use the software and create maps for oral presentation and within 20 minutes they’ve completed a map.
I used iMindmap in earlier versions and found it clunky and limited, but with presentation view and the ease of creating maps now, I’d have to say that, in my limited experience with such software, (I’ve used Mind Genius and NovaMind), iMindmap 4.1 is the most improved piece of software.
[...] the holidays, I told you about a new contest that I’m running to identify the commercial mind mapping program that has improved the most [...]
Just a small note that you could call Mindomo desktop software as well as web software as it features a downloadable local app that syncs with the web SaaS.
Is there a color palette for XMind or only on the pro version